欢迎来到OAJRC平台！
登录 | 注册 | English
期刊目次
加入编委
添加您的邮件地址以接收即将发行期刊数据：
Open Access Article
International Journal of Education. 2021; 3: (1) ; 1-12 ; DOI: 10.12208/j.ije.20210001.
香港城市大学系统工程及工程管理学系 中国香港
*通讯作者： 孙洪义,单位：香港城市大学系统工程及工程管理学系 中国香港；
发布时间: 2021-01-18 总浏览量: 1205
PDF 全文下载 引用本文 收录截图（CNKI-Scholar）
专创融合金课设计等教学改革最终必然会涉及到教学设计。教学设计有两个不同的层次，一个是课程层面的课程大纲的设计（Syllabus design），另外一个层次是详细的单元的教学设计(Unit design)。成果导向已经成为国际公认的课程大纲设计方法，推广认证路线清晰。但是单元教学设计的方法却很多，比如五星法、五步法、有效教学法、BOPPPS、EDDIE、O-AMAS和对分课堂等至少60多种，新的方法还在不断出现。现在也许是时候全面地介绍一下、比较一下和总结一下，并顺便了解一下从教学方法（Teaching method）到教学设计方法（Instructional design method）的发展历程和经验教训。本文首先简要地回顾一下赫尔巴特(Herbart)和杜威(Dewey)经典的教学理念和方法，从中探讨批判思维，因地制宜和与时俱进三个原则的重要性和必然性。然后根据这三个原则，对12种教学设计方法进行了结构性的对比分析，并总结出一套以学生学习为中心，同时保持教学平衡、师生平衡的“六字诀”单元教学设计法（即：入、学、练、用、展、思），让成果导向的教学理念，创新创业教育和专创融合金课设计的方案落地到课堂的每一节课程和教学单元。
Education reforms such as designing the innovation and entrepreneurship embedded golden course will eventually touch instruction design. There are two different levels of instructional design, one is the design at the course level (Syllabus design), and the other is the design at the detailed unit level (Unit design). Outcome-based education (OBE) has become an internationally recognized method for designing syllabus and curriculum accreditation. However, there are as many as 6o different unit instructional design methods such as the Five-star method, Five-step method, Effective education method, BOPPPS, EDDIE, ASSURE, O-AMAS and so on. New methods are still emerging. It is high time to conduct a comprehensive review, comparison and summary, and by the way to understand the development process and lessons from teaching method to instructional design method. This article first briefly reviews the classic teaching concepts and methods by Herbart and Dewey, and then explores the importance and inevitability of the three principles, i.e., critical thinking, adapting measures to local conditions and advancing with the times. Then, based on these three principles, a structural comparative analysis of 12 instructional design methods was carried out, and, as a result, a new instructional design method: the ELPADRe model (Entry, Learn, Practice, Apply, Exhibit, and Reflect). The ELPADRe model is based on student-centered learning while maintaining the balance between teaching and learning. Hopefully the ELPADRe method will implement and operationalize the outcome-based education, innovation and entrepreneurship education and golden course design into every unit of a lesson.
[1] Andrews, D. H., & Goodson, L. A. A comparative analysis of models of instructional design.Journal of instructional development,1980 3 (4) : 2-16.
[2] Bestor, A. E. Educational wastelands. Urbana, University of Illinois Press..1953 .
[3] Bloom, Benjamin S. Taxonomy of Educational Objectives.Published by Allyn and Bacon, Boston, MA. Copyright (c) 1984 by Pearson Education.,1956 .
[4] Dick, W., & Carey, L. The systematic design of instruction (2nd ed.).Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman,1985 .
[5] Ding, Xiaojung丁笑炯. 关于以学生为中心的教学理论与实践的反思——来自西方的经验.全球教育展望,2005 34 (11) : 39-44.
[6] Duffy, T. M., & Cunningham, D. J. Constructivism: Implications for the design and delivery of instruction. In D. Jonassen (Ed.), Handbook of Research for Educational Communications and Technology.New York: Simon & Schuster Macmillan,1996 : 170-198.
[7] Duffy, T. M., & Jonassen, D. H. Constructivism: New implications for instructional technology. In T. Duffy & D. Jonassen (Eds.), Constructivism and the technology of instruction.Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.,1992 : 1-16.
[8] Edmonds, G. S., Branch, R. C., & Mukherjee, P. A conceptual framework for comparing instructional design models..Educational technology research and development,1994 42 (4) : 55-72.
[9] Faryadi, Q.. Instructional Design Models: What a Revolution!.Online Submission,2017 .
[10] Fenrich, P., & Johnson, R. Instructional skills workshops: A model for training professors how to teach..Research Highlights in Education and Science,2016 9 .
[11] Gagne, R. M. Military training and principles of learning.American psychologist,1962 17 (2) : 83-91.
[12] Gardner, D. P. A nation at risk: The imperative for educational reform:.A report to the nation and the Secretary of Education, United States Department of Education. The Commission.,1983 .
[13] Gustafson, K. L., & Branch, R. M. Instructional design models.International Encyclopedia of Adult Educational and Training,1996 : 503-508.
[14] Guo Xiaoping郭晓平. 美国进步主义教育运动的社会意义及失败的教训.北京师范大学学报: 社会科学版,1989 (3) : 103-107.
[15] Heinich, R., & Molenda, MR JD, and Smaldino, SE. Instructional media and technologies for learning.1999 2.2 .
[16] Heinich, R., Molenda, M., Russell, J., & Smaldino, S.. Instructional Media and Technologies for Learning. (6th ed.).Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prince Hall. EDIT 6180 University of Georgia.,1999 .
[17] Kemp, J. E.. The instructional design process. New York.Harper & Row,1985 .
[18] Kurt, S. ASSURE: Instructional Design Model.in Educational Technology,2015 .
[19] Levin, T., & Long, R. Effective Instruction..Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, 225 North Washington Street, Alexandria, VA,1981 .
[20] Mager, R. F.. Preparing objectives for programmed instruction..Pearson Publisher/Lear Siegler, California,1962 .
[21] Mayer, Richard E. Cognition and instruction: Their historic meeting within educational psychology.Journal of Educational Psychology,1992 84 (4) : 405-412.
[22] Merrill, M. D. First principles of instruction.Educational Technology Research and Development,2002 50 (3) : 43-59.
[23] Merrill, M. D.; Drake, L.; Lacy, M. J.; Pratt, J. Reclaiming instructional design.Educational Technology,1996 36 (5) : 5-7.
[24] Morrison, G. R., Ross, S. M., & Kemp, J. E. Designing effective instruction, 4th edition, New York.NY: John Wiley & Sons Inc,2004 .
[25] Neck, H. M., Greene, P. G., & Brush, C. G. Teaching entrepreneurship: A practice-based approach.Edward Elgar Publishing,2014 .
[26] Orlich, D. C., Harder, R. J., Callahan, R. C., Trevisan, M. S., & Brown, A. H. Teaching strategies: A guide to effective instruction.Cengage Learning,2012 .
[27] Pattison, P., & Russell, D. Instructional skills workshop (ISW) handbook.Vancouver: UBC Center for Teaching and Academic Growth,2006 : 42-63.
[28] Reiser, R. A., & Dempsey, J. V. Trends and issues in instructional design and technology.Boston: Pearson,2012 .
[29] Silber, Kenneth; Foshay, Wellesley. Handbook of Improving Performance in the Workplace, Instructional Design and Training Delivery..San Francisco,2010 : 62.
[30] Skinner, B. F. The science of learning and the art of teaching..Cambridge, Mass, USA,1954 : 99-113.
[31] Sun 孙洪义. 专创融合六步法设计金课的系统性和一致性.高等院校创新创业教育教学委员会年会暨 2019 年高等院校创新创业教育教学发展论坛,2019a .
[32] Sun 孙洪义. 用专创融合六步法设计创新创业教育金课.创新创业理论与实践,2019b 3 : 32-44.
[33] Sun孙洪义. 成果导向的创新创业基础 3333 教学大纲和 PIPE 教学方案[J].创新教育研究,2017 5 (2) : 90-102.
[34] Sun孙洪义. 创新创业基础.机械工业出版社,2016 .
[35] Sun, Hongyi. The 3-3-3 Framework and 7P Model for Teaching Creativity, Innovation and Entrepreneurship.Journal of Chinese Entrepreneurship,2011 3 (2) : 159-166.
[36] Sun，孙洪义. 创新人才培养的四个基本问题: 兼叙“3-3-3”课程体系和7P教学模型的探索.创新与创业教育,2010 1 (2) : 8-14.
[37] Tennyson, Robert; Dijkstra, S.; Schott, Frank; Seel, Norbert. Instructional Design: International Perspectives. Theory, research, and models.1997 1 : 42.
[38] Thomas, M., Mitchell, M. & Joseph, R. The third dimension of ADDIE: A cultural embrace.Tech Trends,2002 46 (2) : 40-45.
[39] Wagner, Ellen. Essay: In Search of the Secret Handshakes of ID.The Journal of Applied Instructional Design,2011 1 (1) : 33-37.
[40] Xu续润华. 外国教育史导论.黑龙江人民出版社,2016 08 : 122.
[41] Zhang张学新. 对分课堂:中国教育的新智慧.科学出版社,2017 .
[42] Zhu朱承, 刘聆, 王新峰, 黄金才, & 刘忠. 研讨式课程改进型 “五步” 教学方法.(Doctoral dissertation),2011 .
[43] Zhu朱燕空 祁明德 罗美娟. 创业如何教：基于体验的五步教学法.机械工业出版社,2018 .
入驻平台
回到首页
扫一扫，添加我们